Home » Diet and Weight Loss

Detox Diets: What Works, What Doesn’t

19 March 2009 3 Comments
By Karen Asp (AOLHealth)

Nobody does diets better than Hollywood, and when stars want to slim down fast, they often turn to cleanses. “Through cleanses or detox diets, which are usually low-calorie, liquid diets, you experience fast, significant but short-term weight loss,” says Andrea Giancoli, M.P.H., R.D., spokesperson for the American Dietetic Association who’s in private practice in Los Angeles. The results, however, don’t often last, which is why cleanses aren’t the solution to long-term weight loss. But if you’re trying to slim down for a big event, your body can handle a few days on a cleanse. Here, Giancoli weighs in on eight favorite Hollywood detox diets and tells you which ones are okay to try and which to avoid.

Gwyneth’s Cleanse

When Gwyneth Paltrow wanted to shed “holiday excess,” she turned to a detox specialist, and wound up with a seven-day plan that eliminates dairy, caffeine and processed foods. You’ll enjoy smoothies made with fruit and rice milk or coconut milk and organic foods like chicken and steamed salmon and veggies along with herbal teas, soups and brown rice. Gwyneth’s web site offers lots of detox recipes.

Our expert says: Give it a go. “Of all the cleanses, this is perhaps one of the more healthful ones, as you’re getting substance and nutrients,” Giancoli says.

Master Cleanse

This liquid diet promotes ultra fast weight loss because all you’re allowed to consume is a concoction of water, lemon juice, maple syrup and cayenne pepper; salt water; and an herbal laxative tea. Over the 10- to 30-day diet, you’ll consume only 600 to 1,200 calories a day.

Celeb followers: Beyoncé Knowles

Our expert says: Skip it: It’s way too low in calories and doesn’t provide any nutrition. Plus, when it’s done, you’ll regain the lost weight.

SoCal Cleanse

There’s no crazy dieting or fasting on the SoCal diet. Instead, you choose your cleanse (there are five to pick from), and then you pop two capsules of natural herbs in the morning and another two in the afternoon, which are intended for “internal body detoxification and cleansing.” You’re also encouraged to eat fruits, vegetables and lean protein; avoid processed foods and caffeine; and minimize your sugar intake.

Celeb followers: Lisa Rinna

Our expert says: Save your money. “If you’re eating a diet that includes fruits and veggies, you don’t need these capsules,” Giancoli says.

David Kirsch’s LemonAid 48-hour Detox

Celebrity fitness trainer David Kirsch has whipped numerous Hollywood A-listers into red-carpet shape, many of whom have done this diet. For two days, you drink a glass of LemonAid (a mix of lemon, purified water, maple syrup and cayenne pepper) four times daily. Water, hot tea and a few of Kirsch’s other drink products are also allowed.

Celeb followers: Anne Hathaway, Liv Tyler

Our expert says: A one- or two-day cleanse like this probably won’t hurt you, but it’s not going to be fun or easy.

iZO Cleanze

The iZO Cleanze offers two options: The iZO Juice Feast, a liquid diet available only if you live in the Los Angeles area (although it’s expanding to other cities), and the iZO Superfood Cleanze. With the Juice Feast, organic juices and teas are delivered to your door every morning for as long as you want. On the Superfood Cleanze, which lasts three or seven days, you mix powders into water or juice.

Celeb followers: Allison Janney, Daisy Fuentes, Eva LaRue, Tony Shaloub

Our expert says: Look elsewhere. “Any diet or cleanse that’s product oriented should raise a red flag,” Giancoli says. Besides, it’s expensive and doesn’t provide enough nutrition.

Martha’s Vineyard Detox Diet

Losing 21 pounds in 21 days is the premise of this diet, which consists of fruit and vegetable juices, drinks, soups, enzyme pills, and oh yeah, enemas.

Celeb followers: Angelina Jolie, Robin Quivers

Our expert says: Even though it’s high in fruits and veggies and low in processed foods, this diet promotes dangerous behaviors (like colonics) and unsustainable weight loss, which could be detrimental to the psyche, Giancoli says.

Blueprint Cleanse

Choose from three levels of intensity on this liquid diet, where you’ll be slurping six juice-based “tonics” daily with ingredients that might include cashew nut milk, fruit juices and select spices. On the Renovation Cleanse, which is for beginners, you’ll consume 1,200 calories while you’ll drop to 1,100 calories a day on the Foundation Cleanse. Finally, the Excavation Cleanse, the most hardcore, allows 1,000 calories a day.

Celeb followers: Sarah Jessica Parker

Our expert says: Don’t do it. The calorie count is too low — general guidelines recommend not dipping below 1,200 calories a day, and even that could be too low for many people — and it’s expensive.

Quantum Wellness Cleanse

Created by Kathy Freston, a personal growth and spiritual counselor, this cleanse promotes eating plant-based, fiber-rich foods and eliminating caffeine, sugar, alcohol, gluten and animal products for up to 21 days.

Celeb followers: Oprah

Our expert says: Thumbs up. “I like the focus on plant-based eating, which more Americans should do,” Giancoli says, adding that this diet is more of a healthful approach to eating versus a cleanse. Her only concern? If you’re not sensitive or allergic to gluten, cutting gluten doesn’t make sense, as you’ll skip some key nutrients.

Related Posts
  • Eating for Weight Loss: A Little Goes a Long Way Making healthy food choices is an essential part of any weight loss program, and knowing what to eat can help dieters prepare meals that are wholesome and maximize calorie burn and fat loss. Metabolism Boosters A study published in the April 2004 issue of Obesity Research determined that dieters......
  • Your guide to the healthiest pregnancy By Rebecca Lacko (Examiner.com) The Big Three Scientific research continues to expand our knowledge of nutrition in pregnancy. Let’s begin with the Big Three: protein, calcium and folate. Use the Big Three as building blocks for all your meals. Be sure to include them with every meal to meet recommended......
  • The Twitter Diet By Mary Kearl (AOL Health) Twitter, which you many of you may already use to track the whereabouts and happenings of friends, loved ones, world leaders and celebrities, is also being used to track weight loss and calorie intake, as well as to swap diet tips, recipes, workout routines and......
  • Nordic Walking: Hot New Exercise for 2009 by Michele Cheplic It's the latest fitness trend and it doesn't require a lot of expensive equipment or coordination. Nordic walking is consider the "it" exercise for 2009, according to fitness experts. The simple sport originated in Finland and spread throughout Europe. It is especially popular in Sweden, Norway, Germany,......
  • Foods that can suppress your appetite! From AOL Health Apples An apple a day keeps cravings at bay. High-fiber foods like apples generally require more chewing time, giving your body extra time to register the fact that you're no longer hungry.  Therefore, you're less likely to overeat. One study in Brazil found that women who ate......
Related Websites
  • Start Making Lifestyle Changes It is common knowledge that making lifestyle changes can have a big impact on how much weight you lose and your chances of keeping it off over the long term. What isn’t as clear is how to effect those changes, especially if you are trying to lose weight on your......
  • Weight Loss Secrets pt 3 The right weight loss secrets can go really far in helping you achieve the healthful and natural weight loss that you are looking for. Here are some healthy and natural weight loss secrets. Weight Loss Secret #1 - Chunk up your salad using chopped up carrots, sweet potatoes, celery, zucchini......
  • 3 Day Diet Review 3 day diets are one of the most popular crash diets still around today. A lot of people try this diet, and they do see results, but it is only a short term weight loss. Sadly the weight is gained back quite soon for many people. The three day diet......
  • Calorie Cycling – Is It a Sound Idea? There has been a lot of buzz lately about calorie cycling and whether or not it is an effective means of losing weight. For some, it has enabled them to lose massive amounts of weight. For others, it may just not work. Let’s take a look at the theories behind......
  • Alli is out---Use at your own risk We felt glued to our seats. My wife and I were sitting in a small cafe in southern New Hampshire---the only diners in the place---and on the TV in the corner was Neil Cavuto on Fox TV conducting an interview (a debate, really) about the new over-the-counter weight-loss pill......

3 Comments »

  • Lucille Felton said:

    Thank you for putting all of this valuable information in one place! There are so many options to choose from. I am currently using the Master Cleanse, which is intense. But I am losing about 1 to 2 pounds a day so far (all that gunky packed-in waste). For long term, I may try a raw food type diet that will give me the nutrients that I need while dieting. Again, thanks for all the useful information!

  • Twitted by WeightLadder said:

    [...] This post was Twitted by WeightLadder [...]

  • alice said:

    this information is very helpful.
    Please provide more.
    ————————
    alice

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree